Skip to main content

Site Banner Ads

Site Search

Search

Home Up Here Publishing

Mobile Toggle

Social Links

Facebook Instagram

Search Toggle

Search

Main navigation

  • Magazines
    • Latest Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Up Here Business
    • Visitor Guides
    • Move Up Here
  • Sections
    • People & Places
    • Arts & Lifestyle
    • History & Culture
    • Travel & Tourism
    • Nature & Science
    • Northern Jobs
  • Newsletter
  • Community Map
  • Merch
  • Visitor Guides
  • Our Team
  • Subscribe/Renew

All-American Arctic?

How a U.S. politician sought to buy Greenland and Iceland to get at Canada

By Herb Mathisen

Illustration by Beth Covvey

Illustration by Beth Covvey

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. All-American Arctic?

If the United States were to purchase Iceland and Greenland, it follows that Canada—now flanked to the west by recently acquired Alaska and to the east by these new possessions—would be compelled “peacefully and cheerfully, to become a part of the American Union.” This from a report compiled by a mining engineer named Benjamin Mills Pierce in late 1867, on the recommendation of then-American secretary of state William H. Seward.

Seward had been keen on expansion—particularly to the North—throughout his political career. He was first elected to the U.S. senate in 1849 and became Abraham Lincoln’s Secretary of State, a title he carried during the Civil War and afterwards. Seward was part of a long line of American leaders who believed in Manifest Destiny—the U.S. would one day control all of North America. He figured British North America (before it became Canada) could be convinced to join the United States.

He recognized the land’s vast resource potential. Writing in his journal in 1857 during a fishing trip in Labrador, he marvelled at the “wheat-fields in the West, its broad ranges of chase at the North, its inexhaustible lumber lands, the most extensive now remaining on the globe, its invaluable fisheries and its yet undisturbed mines.”

The U.S. Civil War erupted in 1861 and any ideas Seward had were put on hold. When the gruesome fighting ended four years later, the U.S. government had a massive reconstruction effort ahead of it. Meanwhile, negotiations intensified to unify provinces under the Dominion of Canada.

Then, in 1867, the dominoes started to fall. Russia approached Seward about his interest in Alaska. Russia, still reeling economically following the Crimean War, found it too costly to maintain its interests in Alaska and it did not want the territory to fall to the British. The two sides swiftly negotiated a US$7.2-million price (roughly $125 million today) for Alaska. The U.S. now had a piece of the Arctic.

Just days earlier, Queen Victoria had signed the British North America Act to create the Dominion of Canada. Still, Canadian leaders were fretting about possible American expansion. With good reason: Seward and his contemporaries thought the territories which had not yet signed onto Confederation—including British Columbia and Rupert’s Land (owned by the Hudson’s Bay Company)—could be persuaded to join the U.S. now that it was bordered by Alaska to the northwest. (They even sent spies to the Red River to assess local sentiment towards America.) Taking the next step in Seward’s logic, if the U.S. could acquire Greenland and Iceland, perhaps all of Canada would acquiesce.

How close was this to happening?

“I don’t think there was a ghost of a chance,” says Shelagh Grant, historian and author of the comprehensive history of Arctic and North American sovereignty, Polar Imperative. There were many reasons why. First, Seward had already expended his political capital with the Alaska Purchase, which some dubbed Seward’s Folly. In the aftermath of the Civil War, the Americans had the huge task of rebuilding their country and money spent on a faraway tract of Arctic land appeared frivolous in contrast.

Further, Grant believes Seward also underestimated the devotion—even
anti-Americanism—from the population north of the border. “The Americans did not truly recognize the strength of British loyalty in British North America,” she says. Seward’s plan to induce the annexation of British Columbia and Rupert’s Land to the U.S. proved a tactical miscalculation, she argues in Polar Imperative—it actually provided Canada with added motivation to bring the two territories into the fold.

But the scenario presents an interesting ‘what if’ question.

Had Seward succeeded, Grant believes much of the west and north would have been nothing more than a treasure chest of water, wood and other mineral resources to be sent to the most productive areas of the United States.

“Somebody will say we’re doing that anyways,” Grant says with a laugh.

Related Articles

Tear Sheet

Hunters of the twilight

Hunters Of The Twilight

The Inuit of northern Baffin Island's Admiralty Inlet still survive by the hard-earned skills of their ancestors.

October 16th, 2025 October 16th, 2025

Tear Sheet

-----

The Tundra Still Holds Its Secrets

Lost aircraft are an inseparable part of Northern lore. Here are forlorn tales of the most mysterious. 

October 16th, 2025 October 16th, 2025

UP HERE - MAY/JUN 2025

----

Them’s Fightin’ Words

The Godsells expected something different when they moved to Fort Fitzgerald. A punch-up wasn’t it

October 16th, 2025 October 16th, 2025

UP HERE - MAY/JUN 2025

Photo by Bill Braden

Birthday Buck

Yellowknife celebrated the NWT’s centennial with an idea that was so money

October 16th, 2025 October 16th, 2025

UP HERE - JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2024

Lindblad explorer

BACK TO 1984

When the world seemed full of promise.

October 16th, 2025 October 16th, 2025

UP HERE - SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2023

Gates of Pioneer Cemetery

The Grave Story Of Pioneer Cemetery

A milestone of Whitehorse’s history was once ignored by officials, and reviled by locals. 

October 16th, 2025 October 16th, 2025
Newsletter sign-up promo image.

Stay in Touch.

Our weekly newsletter brings all the best circumpolar stories right to your inbox.

Up Here magazine cover

Subscribe Now

Our magazine showcases award-winning writing and spectacular northern photos.

Subscribe

Footer Navigation

  • Advertise With Us
  • Write for Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimers & Legal

Contact Information

Up Here Publishing
P.O Box 1343
Yellowknife, NT
X1A 2N9  Canada
Email: info@uphere.ca

Social Links

Facebook Instagram
Funded by the Government of Canada